As the Christmas trading period approaches, many Irish businesses take on extra staff to help manage the increased volume of trade. Whether employing staff on fixed term contracts, casual workers or using recruitment agencies, there are different levels of flexibility and different legal obligations with each.
Temporary workers generally enjoy the same statutory employment rights as permanent employees. Therefore, it is important for employers to be aware of their obligations and consider which arrangement is best for their business.
Fixed Term Employees
Fixed term employees are hired for a specified period, e.g. November until early January. The employment contract will specify the end date or another objective condition that will result in the end of employment.
Employers need to ensure:
The contract clearly sets out the fixed term nature of the employment and when it will end.
Employees receive their statutory entitlements, such as annual leave and public holiday benefits.
Any probationary period is proportionate to the contract length.
Appropriate provisions are included for the contract expiry.
Fixed term contracts are particularly useful where businesses can reasonably anticipate the length of time they will need extra staffing.
Casual Employees
Casual employment is flexible, which is useful when there is a fluctuation in staffing requirements, particularly in businesses such as hospitality, retail and events.
Casual employees are generally employed on an occasional, as-needed basis. However, just because you describe someone as a casual employee, this does not mean that they are not entitled to statutory employment rights.
Employers need to be aware of the following:
Casual employees are still entitled to applicable statutory protections, such as annual leave and public holiday benefits.
Contractual terms must reflect the actual working arrangements.
Generally, there is a restriction on the use of zero hours contracts in Ireland, but there are exceptions for genuinely casual work.
There may be additional obligations in relation to contractual hours if there are regular working patterns.
If casual employees are working regular hours on a consistent basis, employers should consider whether the contractual terms accurately reflect the working arrangements.
Temporary Agency Workers
Businesses can use recruitment agencies as an alternative way to source temporary staff. This can be a quicker way to recruit and there is the benefit of the agency managing the payroll administration.
Agency workers are generally employed and paid by the agency, but work under the direction and supervision of the hiring business.
There is a right for agency workers to receive equal treatment in relation to certain basic working conditions, such as pay, working hours, rest periods, annual leave and public holidays.
The hiring business also has responsibilities for workplace health and safety, day-to-day supervision and providing the agency with the correct information in relation to applicable working conditions.
Often Overlooked Unfair Dismissal Risk
There is a misconception that recruitment agencies take on all employment related liabilities.
Under Section 13 of the Unfair Dismissals (Amendment) Act 1993, the hiring business is deemed the employer for the purposes of the Unfair Dismissals Acts.
So, even though an agency worker may be employed and paid by the agency, the hiring business could face an unfair dismissal claim in relation to the termination of the assignment.
The normal eligibility requirements and statutory exceptions will still apply. However, simply asking for a replacement worker does not necessarily mitigate the risk of a claim.
If there are issues in relation to performance or conduct of an agency worker, you should engage with the recruitment agency before terminating the assignment. Document any issues and ensure decisions are reasonable and procedurally fair.
Employment Law Obligations
Whatever employment arrangement is in place, employers need to ensure statutory obligations are met.
Written Terms of Employment: Directly employed staff must be provided with core written employment terms within 5 days of starting employment and a fuller written statement within 1 month.
For agency workers, generally it is the responsibility of the agency (as employer) to issue the required written terms.
Health and Safety: All workers must be provided with appropriate workplace safety information, instruction and training. Hiring businesses have health and safety responsibilities for agency workers working within their workplace.
Working Time and Leave: Employers need to monitor working hours, rest periods, annual leave and public holiday entitlements, including for employees employed on a temporary basis.
Before Recruiting Christmas Staff
Employers should consider:
What is the best employment arrangement for the business staffing requirements?
Are the contractual terms reflective of the intended working arrangements?
What are the statutory entitlements for temporary workers?
What are your responsibilities when using agency workers, particularly in relation to health and safety and unfair dismissal?
How will you manage performance, conduct and end of employment/assignment?
The WorkWise Perspective
Temporary recruitment is a great way to provide flexibility during busy trading periods. However, it is important for employers to consider the legal implications of their chosen employment arrangements.
In particular, agency workers need to be considered. Whilst the agency may be responsible for recruitment, contracts and payroll, the hiring business can have significant legal responsibilities, including the potential for unfair dismissal claims.
WorkWise HR Solutions can assist employers with temporary recruitment arrangements, employment contracts, agency worker obligations and Irish employment law compliance.
Planning Christmas recruitment? Contact WorkWise HR Solutions for practical advice for your business.
